Shifted-echo MQ-MAS phase cycling
Below are presented phase cycling procedures [D. Massiot, B. Touzo,
D. Trumeau, J. P. Coutures, J. Virlet, P. Florian, and P. J. Grandinetti,
Solid State NMR 6, 73-83 (1996)] for MQ-MAS with shifted-echo sequence
applied to half-integer quadrupole spins:
(1) in amplitude-modulated experiment involving two coherence transfer pathways,
(2) in phase-modulated experiment involving one coherence transfer pathway.
We only consider the usual case where the receiver can take four phases: 0°, 90°, 180°, and 270°.
Two approaches are used for the simulation of the echo and/or antiecho
amplitudes with SIMPSON1.1.1 Tcl scripts:
(1) filtering the desired coherences;
(2) explicit phase cycling the pulses and the receiver.
These two approaches are applied to the two practical cases:
(1) the three pulses have strong amplitudes;
(2) the first two pulses have strong amplitudes and the third has a weak amplitude.
For three-pulse sequences such as shifted-echo 3Q-MAS experiments, these two approaches provide the same simulation data about echo and/or antiecho amplitudes whatever the nature (strong or not) of the third pulse.
Outline (A) Amplitude-modulated experiment (A.1) Three strong amplitude pulses (A.1.a) ±3Q-MAS for spin I = 3/2 system (1) 48-phase cycling (2) Simulation (3) Result (A.1.b) ±5Q-MAS for spin I = 5/2 system (1) 80-phase cycling (2) Simulation (3) Result (A.2) Two strong amplitude pulses and one soft pulse (A.2.a) ±3Q-MAS for spin I = 3/2 system (1) 24-phase cycling (2) Simulation (3) Result (A.2.b) ±3Q-MAS for spin I = 5/2 system (1) 24-phase cycling (2) Simulation (3) Result (A.2.c) ±5Q-MAS for spin I = 5/2 system (1) 40-phase cycling (2) Simulation (3) Result (B) Phase-modulated experiment (B.1) Three strong amplitude pulses (B.1.a) -3Q-MAS for spin I = 3/2 system (1) 96-phase cycling (2) Simulation (3) Result (B.1.b) +3Q-MAS for spin I = 3/2 system (1) 96-phase cycling (2) Simulation (3) Result (B.2) Two strong amplitude pulses and one soft pulse (B.2.a) -3Q-MAS for spin I = 3/2 system (1) 48-phase cycling (2) Simulation (3) Result (B.2.b) +3Q-MAS for spin I = 3/2 system (1) 48-phase cycling (2) Simulation (3) Result (C) Conclusion |
(A) Amplitude-modulated experiment
(A.1) Three strong amplitude pulses
The pulse sequence consists of three strong amplitude pulses.
(A.1.a) ±3Q-MAS for spin I = 3/2 system
In amplitude-modulated experiment, two coherence transfer pathways 0Q -> -3Q -> +1Q -> -1Q and 0Q -> +3Q -> +1Q ->-1Q are selected. The phase cycling is defined with the two coherence transfer pathways. That is, the phase cycling must be identical for the two coherence transfer pathways.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/39c62/39c62dd55e69c5ebcadd11d5e8f29b6e06edc695" alt="3Q echo and antiecho coherence transfer pathway in shifted-echo sequence 3Q echo and antiecho coherence transfer pathway in shifted-echo sequence"
The total pathway phase φpath for the coherence transfer pathway
0Q -> -3Q -> +1Q -> -1Q is defined by:
φpath = -3*φ1 + 4*φ2 - 2*φ3 + φrec,
that for the coherence transfer pathway 0Q -> +3Q -> +1Q -> -1Q is defined by:
φpath = +3*φ1 - 2*φ2 - 2*φ3 + φrec,
where
φ1 is the first-pulse phase;
φ2 is the second-pulse phase;
φ3 is the third-pulse phase;
φrec is the receiver phase.
(1) 48-phase cycling
The receiver phase is defined with the conditions: φpath = 0
and φ2 = 0. Therefore, we have two equations
for the receiver phase with two parameters:
φrec = +3*φ1 + 2*φ3,
φrec = -3*φ1 + 2*φ3.
The corresponding solution is: φ1 takes six values; φ3 takes eight values.
φ1 | 0° 60° 120° 180° 240° 300° |
---|---|
φ2 | 0° |
φ3 | {0°}X6 {45°}X6 {90°}X6 {135°}X6 {180°}X6 {225°}X6 {270°}X6 {315°}X6 |
φrec | {0° 180°}X3 {90° 270°}X3 {180° 0°}X3 {270° 90°}X3 |
This phase cycling procedure is also used by [Vosegaard and coworkers, Multiple quantum magic-angle-spinning using rotary resonance excitation, J. Chem. Phys. 114, 4618-4624 (2001)].
(2) Simulation
We provide SIMPSON1.1.1 Tcl scripts for simulating the echo and antiecho
amplitude versus a pulse duration with two approaches:
(1) filtering the desired coherences (-3Q and 3Q after the first pulse and
+1Q after the second pulse);
(2) explicit phase cycling the pulses and the receiver.
Duration | Filtering | 48-phase cycling |
---|---|---|
1st-pulse | na-filtering-p1 | na-48-cycling-p1 |
2nd-pulse | na-filtering-p2 | na-48-cycling-p2 |
3rd-pulse | na-filtering-p3 | na-48-cycling-p3 |
(3) Result
When the amplitudes are normalized to the number of phase cycling, these two approaches provide the same simulation data about echo and antiecho amplitude for spin I = 3/2 and 5/2 systems. For spin I = 7/2 systems, this 48-phase cycling also allows the coherence transfer pathways 0Q -> ±3Q -> -7Q -> -1Q to be detected.
(A.1.b) ±5Q-MAS for spin I = 5/2 system
(1) 80-phase cycling
The receiver phase is defined with the conditions: φpath = 0
and φ2 = 0. Therefore, we have two equations
for the receiver phase with two parameters:
φrec = +5*φ1 + 2*φ3,
φrec = -5*φ1 + 2*φ3.
The corresponding solution is: φ1 takes ten values; φ3 takes eight values.
φ1 | 0° 36° 72° 108° 144° 180° 216° 252° 288° 324° |
---|---|
φ2 | 0° |
φ3 | {0°}X10 {45°}X10 {90°}X10 {135°}X10 {180°}X10 {225°}X10 {270°}X10 {315°}X10 |
φrec | {0° 180°}X5 {90° 270°}X5 {180° 0°}X5 {270° 90°}X5 |
(2) Simulation
We provide SIMPSON1.1.1 Tcl scripts for simulating the echo and antiecho
amplitude versus a pulse duration with two approaches:
(1) filtering the desired coherences (-5Q and 5Q after the first pulse and
+1Q after the second pulse);
(2) explicit phase cycling the pulses and the receiver.
Duration | Filtering | 80-phase cycling |
---|---|---|
1st-pulse | al-filtering-p1 | al-80-cycling-p1 |
2nd-pulse | al-filtering-p2 | al-80-cycling-p2 |
3rd-pulse | al-filtering-p3 | al-80-cycling-p3 |
(3) Result
When the amplitudes are normalized to the number of phase cycling, these two approaches provide the same simulation data about echo and antiecho amplitude for spin I = 5/2 systems. For spin I = 7/2 systems, this 80-phase cycling also allows the coherence transfer pathways 0Q -> ±5Q -> -7Q -> -1Q to be detected.
(A.2) Two strong amplitude pulses and one soft pulse
The first two pulses of the sequence have strong amplitudes whereas the third pulse has a weak amplitude.
(A.2.a) ±3Q-MAS for spin I = 3/2 system
When the third pulse has a weak amplitude, a four-phase cycling is applied to this pulse instead of eight-phase cycling in the strong amplitude case. As a result, the number of phase cycling reduces to 24.
(1) 24-phase cycling
The following phase cycling is applied:
φ1 | 0° 60° 120° 180° 240° 300° |
---|---|
φ2 | 0° |
φ3 | {0°}X6 {90°}X6 {180°}X6 {270°}X6 |
φrec | {0° 180°}X3 {180° 0°}X3 |
This 24-phase cycling selects not only the desired coherence transfer pathways
0Q -> ±3Q -> +1Q -> -1Q,
but also the coherence transfer pathways
0Q -> ±3Q -> -3Q -> -1Q,
as shown in the following figure:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c3a83/c3a83312394d3da5784a9e686ce80d393efb36ff" alt="coherence transfer pathways in shifted-echo sequence with soft pulse coherence transfer pathways in shifted-echo sequence with soft pulse"
(2) Simulation
We provide SIMPSON1.1.1 Tcl scripts for simulating the echo and antiecho
amplitude versus a pulse duration with two approaches:
(1) filtering the coherences (-3Q and 3Q after the first pulse, and
+1Q and -3Q after the second pulse);
(2) explicit phase cycling the pulses and the receiver.
Duration | Filtering | 24-phase cycling |
---|---|---|
1st-pulse | na-select-filt-p1 | na-select-24-cycl-p1 |
2nd-pulse | na-select-filt-p2 | na-select-24-cycl-p2 |
3rd-pulse | na-select-filt-p3 | na-select-24-cycl-p3 |
(3) Result
When the amplitudes are normalized to the number of phase cycling, these two approaches provide the same simulation data about echo and antiecho amplitude for spin I = 3/2 systems.
(A.2.b) ±3Q-MAS for spin I = 5/2 system
The above 24-phase cycling is also applicable to spin I = 5/2 systems.
(1) 24-phase cycling
This 24-phase cycling selects not only the desired coherence transfer pathways
0Q -> ±3Q -> +1Q -> -1Q,
but also the coherence transfer pathways
0Q -> ±3Q -> -3Q -> -1Q and 0Q -> ±3Q -> +5Q -> -1Q
as shown in the following figure:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dd32b/dd32be4df60e84984f67a5b0b802371dc9f99ada" alt="Spin I = 5/2 coherence transfer pathways in shifted-echo sequence with soft pulse Spin I = 5/2 coherence transfer pathways in shifted-echo sequence with soft pulse"
(2) Simulation
We provide SIMPSON1.1.1 Tcl scripts for simulating the echo and antiecho
amplitude versus a pulse duration with two approaches:
(1) filtering the coherences (-3Q and 3Q after the first pulse, and
+1Q, +5Q, and -3Q after the second pulse);
(2) explicit phase cycling the pulses and the receiver.
Duration | Filtering | 24-phase cycling |
---|---|---|
1st-pulse | al-select-filt-p1 | al-select-24-cycl-p1 |
2nd-pulse | al-select-filt-p2 | al-select-24-cycl-p2 |
3rd-pulse | al-select-filt-p3 | al-select-24-cycl-p3 |
(3) Result
When the amplitudes are normalized to the number of phase cycling, these two approaches provide the same simulation data about echo and antiecho amplitude for spin I = 5/2 systems.
(A.2.c) ±5Q-MAS for spin I = 5/2 system
(1) 40-phase cycling
Since four-phase cycling is applied to the weak amplitude pulse, the following 40-phase cycling is applied:
φ1 | 0° 36° 72° 108° 144° 180° 216° 252° 288° 324° |
---|---|
φ2 | 0° |
φ3 | {0°}X10 {90°}X10 {180°}X10 {270°}X10 |
φrec | {0° 180°}X5 {180° 0°}X5 |
This 40-phase cycling selects not only the desired coherence transfer pathways
0Q -> ±5Q -> +1Q -> -1Q,
but also the coherence transfer pathways
0Q -> ±5Q -> -3Q -> -1Q and 0Q -> ±5Q -> +5Q -> -1Q ,
as shown in the following figure:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b1e3e/b1e3e0e3438e3948dcc822325f357cbbcb620047" alt="coherence transfer pathways in shifted-echo sequence with soft pulse coherence transfer pathways in shifted-echo sequence with soft pulse"
(2) Simulation
We provide SIMPSON1.1.1 Tcl scripts for simulating the echo and antiecho
amplitude versus a pulse duration with two approaches:
(1) filtering the coherences (-5Q and 5Q after the first pulse, and
+1Q, -3Q, and 5Q after the second pulse);
(2) explicit phase cycling the pulses and the receiver.
Duration | Filtering | 40-phase cycling |
---|---|---|
1st-pulse | al-select-filt-p1 | al-select-40-cycl-p1 |
2nd-pulse | al-select-filt-p2 | al-select-40-cycl-p2 |
3rd-pulse | al-select-filt-p3 | al-select-40-cycl-p3 |
(3) Result
When the amplitudes are normalized to the number of phase cycling, these two approaches provide the same simulation data about echo and antiecho amplitude for spin I = 5/2 systems.
(B) Phase-modulated experiment
(B.1) Three strong amplitude pulses
In phase-modulated experiment, phase cycling is defined with the desired coherence transfer pathway. Since the coherence transfer pathways are identical to those involved in split-t1 experiments, these phase cycling procedures are applicable for both experiments.
(B.1.a) -3Q-MAS for spin I = 3/2 system
We discuss the echo coherence transfer pathway for a spin I = 3/2 system.
(1) 96-phase cycling
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bf40a/bf40a422b275942f96d4d628889de836927fa982" alt="-3Q echo coherence transfer pathway for I = 3/2 in shifted-echo sequence -3Q echo coherence transfer pathway for I = 3/2 in shifted-echo sequence"
The total pathway phase φpath for the coherence transfer pathway
0Q -> -3Q -> +1Q -> -1Q is defined by:
φpath = -3*φ1 + 4*φ2 - 2*φ3 + φrec.
The receiver phase is defined with the conditions: φpath = 0 and φ2 = 0 ;
therefore φrec = 3*φ1 + 2*φ3.
φ1 takes 12 values;
φ3 takes eight values.
φ1 | 0° 30° 60° 90° 120° 150° 180° 210° 240° 270° 300° 330° |
---|---|
φ2 | 0° |
φ3 | {0°}X12 {45°}X12 {90°}X12 {135°}X12 {180°}X12 {225°}X12 {270°}X12 {315°}X12 |
φrec | {0° 90° 180° 270°}X3 {90° 180° 270° 0°}X3 {180° 270° 0° 90°}X3 {270° 0° 90° 180°}X3 |
This phase cycling procedure is also provided by [S. P. Brown and S. Wimperis Two-dimensional MQ-MAS NMR of quadrupolar nuclei: a comparison of methods, J. Magn. Reson. 128, 42-61 (1997)].
(2) Simulation
We provide SIMPSON1.1.1 Tcl scripts for simulating the echo amplitude versus a
pulse duration with two approaches:
(1) filtering the desired coherences (-3Q after the first pulse and +1Q after the
second pulse);
(2) explicit phase cycling the pulses and the receiver.
Duration | Filtering | 96-phase cycling |
---|---|---|
1st-pulse | na-echo-filt-p1 | na-echo-96-cycl-p1 |
2nd-pulse | na-echo-filt-p2 | na-echo-96-cycl-p2 |
3rd-pulse | na-echo-filt-p3 | na-echo-96-cycl-p3 |
(3) Result
When the amplitudes are normalized to the number of phase cycling, these two approaches provide the same simulation data about echo amplitude for spin I = 3/2 and about antiecho amplitude for spin I = 5/2 systems. For spin I = 7/2 systems, this 96-phase cycling also allows the coherence transfer pathway 0Q -> -3Q -> -7Q -> -1Q to be detected.
(B.1.b) +3Q-MAS for spin I = 3/2 system
We discuss the antiecho coherence transfer pathway for a spin I = 3/2 system.
(1) 96-phase cycling
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d606e/d606e12568b354790492e087c3b90435d360603b" alt="3Q echo coherence transfer pathway for I = 3/2 in shifted-echo sequence 3Q echo coherence transfer pathway for I = 3/2 in shifted-echo sequence"
The total pathway phase φpath for the coherence transfer pathway
0Q -> +3Q -> +1Q -> -1Q is defined by:
φpath = 3*φ1 - 2*φ2 - 2*φ3 + φrec.
The receiver phase is defined with the conditions: φpath = 0 and φ2 = 0;
therefore φrec = -3*φ1 + 2*φ3.
φ1 takes 12 values;
φ3 takes eight values.
φ1 | 0° 30° 60° 90° 120° 150° 180° 210° 240° 270° 300° 330° |
---|---|
φ2 | 0° |
φ3 | {0°}X12 {45°}X12 {90°}X12 {135°}X12 {180°}X12 {225°}X12 {270°}X12 {315°}X12 |
φrec | {0° 270° 180° 90°}X3 {90° 0° 270° 180°}X3 {180° 90° 0° 270°}X3 {270° 180° 90° 0°}X3 |
This phase cycling procedure is also provided by [S. P. Brown and S. Wimperis Two-dimensional MQ-MAS NMR of quadrupolar nuclei: a comparison of methods, J. Magn. Reson. 128, 42-61 (1997)].
(2) Simulation
We provide SIMPSON1.1.1 Tcl scripts for simulating the antiecho amplitude versus a
pulse duration with two approaches:
(1) filtering the desired coherences (+3Q after the first pulse and +1Q after the
second pulse);
(2) explicit phase cycling the pulses and the receiver.
Duration | Filtering | 96-phase cycling |
---|---|---|
1st-pulse | na-anti-filt-p1 | na-anti-96-cycl-p1 |
2nd-pulse | na-anti-filt-p2 | na-anti-96-cycl-p2 |
3rd-pulse | na-anti-filt-p3 | na-anti-96-cycl-p3 |
(3) Result
When the amplitudes are normalized to the number of phase cycling, these two approaches provide the same simulation date about antiecho amplitude for spin I = 3/2 systems and about echo amplitude for spin I = 5/2 systems. For spin I = 7/2 systems, this 96-phase cycling also allows the coherence transfer pathway 0Q -> +3Q -> -7Q -> -1Q to be detected.
(B.2) Two strong amplitude pulses and one soft pulse
The first two pulses of the sequence have strong amplitudes whereas the third pulse has a weak amplitude.
(B.2.a) -3Q-MAS for spin I = 3/2 system
When the third pulse has a weak amplitude, a four-phase cycling is applied to this pulse instead of eight-phase cycling in the strong amplitude case. As a result, the number of phase cycling reduces to 48.
(1) 48-phase cycling
The following phase cycling is applied:
φ1 | 0° 30° 60° 90° 120° 150° 180° 210° 240° 270° 300° 330° |
---|---|
φ2 | 0° |
φ3 | {0°}X12 {90°}X12 {180°}X12 {270°}X12 |
φrec | {0° 90° 180° 270°}X3 {180° 270° 0° 90°}X3 |
This 48-phase cycling selects not only the desired coherence transfer pathway
0Q -> -3Q -> +1Q -> -1Q,
but also the coherence transfer pathway
0Q -> -3Q -> -3Q -> -1Q,
as shown in the following figure:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bba6a/bba6aff40f85b5462a0f7ca7fdb5b1379ec9b871" alt="-3Q echo coherence transfer pathway for I = 3/2 in shifted-echo sequence with soft pulse -3Q echo coherence transfer pathway for I = 3/2 in shifted-echo sequence with soft pulse"
(2) Simulation
We provide SIMPSON1.1.1 Tcl scripts for simulating the echo amplitude versus a
pulse duration with two approaches:
(1) filtering the coherences (-3Q after the first pulse, and +1Q and -3Q after the
second pulse);
(2) explicit phase cycling the pulses and the receiver.
Duration | Filtering | 48-phase cycling |
---|---|---|
1st-pulse | na-echo-sel-filt-p1 | na-echo-sel-cycl-p1 |
2nd-pulse | na-echo-sel-filt-p2 | na-echo-sel-cycl-p2 |
3rd-pulse | na-echo-sel-filt-p3 | na-echo-sel-cycl-p3 |
(3) Result
When the amplitudes are normalized to the number of phase cycling, these two approaches provide the same simulation data about echo amplitude for spin I = 3/2 systems.
(B.2.b) +3Q-MAS for spin I = 3/2 system
We discuss the antiecho coherence transfer pathway for a spin I = 3/2 system.
(1) 48-phase cycling
The following 48-phase cycling is applied:
φ1 | 0° 30° 60° 90° 120° 150° 180° 210° 240° 270° 300° 330° |
---|---|
φ2 | 0° |
φ3 | {0°}X12 {90°}X12 {180°}X12 {270°}X12 |
φrec | {0° 270° 180° 90°}X3 {180° 90° 0° 270°}X3 |
This 48-phase cycling selects not only the desired coherence transfer pathway
0Q -> +3Q -> +1Q -> -1Q,
but also the coherence transfer pathway
0Q -> +3Q -> -3Q -> -1Q,
as shown in the following figure:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4ddd5/4ddd5717d43f5fa7c413703d07e66ac1044a230a" alt="3Q echo coherence transfer pathway for I = 3/2 in shifted-echo sequence with soft pulse 3Q echo coherence transfer pathway for I = 3/2 in shifted-echo sequence with soft pulse"
(2) Simulation
We provide SIMPSON1.1.1 Tcl scripts for simulating the antiecho amplitude versus a
pulse duration with two approaches:
(1) filtering the coherences (+3Q after the first pulse, and +1Q and -3Q after the
second pulse);
(2) explicit phase cycling the pulses and the receiver.
Duration | Filtering | 48-phase cycling |
---|---|---|
1st-pulse | na-anti-sel-filt-p1 | na-anti-sel-48-cycl-p1 |
2nd-pulse | na-anti-sel-filt-p2 | na-anti-sel-48-cycl-p2 |
3rd-pulse | na-anti-sel-filt-p3 | na-anti-sel-48-cycl-p3 |
(3) Result
When the amplitudes are normalized to the number of phase cycling, these two approaches provide the same simulation date about antiecho amplitude for spin I = 3/2.
(C) Conclusion
In shifted-echo experiments for I = 3/2 and 5/2 systems, two cases are presented:
- the three pulses have strong amplitudes - the desired coherence transfer pathways are selected by phase cycling;
- the first two pulses have strong amplitudes and the third pulse has a weak amplitude - not only the desired coherence transfer pathways are selected, but additional coherence transfer pathways are also selected by phase cycling.
In the two cases, the variation of the echo and/or antiecho amplitudes versus a pulse duration can be simulated with coherence filtering method and phase cycling method. But the coherence filtering method provides the results in much shorter time.