One-pulse line intensity for MAS crystal, Part 1
AIM: We show that SIMPSON1.1.0 Tcl script with a negative value of the asymmetry parameter η generates wrong results. However, SIMPSON1.1.1 Tcl script provides us with right results.
Equipment: Mathematica-5 (or MathReader for reading the notebook if you do not have Mathematica-5), SIMPSON1.1.0, and SIMPSON1.1.1.
Definition: The NMR line intensity, which depends on the various interactions involved during the RF pulses, is proportional to the amplitude of the first sampled point of a free-induction decay or the integrated area of the corresponding spectrum.
Method: We simulate the central-line intensities of a spin I = 3/2 for pulse duration t increasing from 0 to 20 µs by steps of 1 µs in a crystal rotating at the magic angle, using Mathematica-5 notebook and SIMPSON Tcl script.
The parameters for these simulations are:
- Observed line intensity: central transition (中心躍遷)
- Nucleus: 23Na
- Spin: 3/2
- 23Na Larmor frequency: 105.8731007 MHz
- Proton Larmor frequency: 400 MHz
- Strength of the radio-frequency pulse: 100 kHz
- Initial pulse duration: 0
- Final pulse duration: 20 µs
- Pulse duration increment: 1 µs
- Number of pulse duration increment: 20
- Rotor spinning speed (轉子的轉速): 15 kHz
- Quadrupole interaction: first and second orders
- Quadrupole coupling constant: 8 MHz
- Asymmetry parameter: -1 or 1
- Euler angle α of the rotor in the PAS of the EFG tensor: 30°
- Euler angle β of the rotor in the PAS of the EFG tensor: 30°
- Euler angle γ of the rotor in the PAS of the EFG tensor: 30°
(A) Mathematica-5 notebook
- Download the Mathematica-5 notebook called crystal_MAS.nb or the notebook as PDF file crystal_MAS.pdf (51 Kb)
- Save this file into the software Mathematica 5 folder.
- Open this file with Mathematica-5 and change the value of the asymmetry parameter.
- Press "Ctrl-A" to select the notebook, then press "Shift-enter" to start simulation.
- A file called crystalMAS.m is created in Mathematica-5 folder. MS Excel can open this file.
(B) SIMPSON Tcl script
- Select and paste the following green lines in MS Bloc-notes.
- Save this file as "onextalMAS.in" into the software SIMPSON folder.
- Modify the value of the asymmetry parameter and save modification.
- Run this SIMPSON Tcl script in a DOS window.
- The simulated line intensities are saved in a file called onextalMAS.fid in SIMPSON folder.
SIMPSON Tcl script# onextalMAS.in # Spin-3/2 central-line intensity calculation # for a crystal rotating at the magic angle, # submitted to the first- and the second-order # quadrupole interactions. spinsys { channels 23Na nuclei 23Na quadrupole 1 2 8e6 1 30 30 30 } par { proton_frequency 400e6 spin_rate 15000 variable tsw 1 sw 1.0e6/tsw np 21 crystal_file alpha0beta0 gamma_angles 1 start_operator 0.2*I1z detect_operator I1c verbose 1101 variable rf 100000 } proc pulseq {} { global par maxdt $par(tsw) acq for {set i 1} {$i < $par(np)} {incr i} { pulse $par(tsw) $par(rf) x acq -y } } proc main {} { global par fsave [fsimpson] $par(name).fid puts "Larmor frequency (Hz) of 23Na: " puts [resfreq 23Na $par(proton_frequency)] } |
CommentFile name. Description. Spin I = 3/2. 1st- and 2nd-order quadrupole interactions, qcc = 8 MHz, eta = 1, αPC = 30°, βPC = 30°, γPC = 30°. MAS crystal. 1 µs pulse increment. 20 pulse increments. 0.2 for normalization. Central-transition. 100 kHz RF pulse. 1 µs pulse increment. No pulse, no signal. Variable x-pulse. Receiver phase -y. |
(C) Result
The simulated line intensities are gathered in the following table.
t (μs) |
Mathematica-5 crystal_MAS.nb |
SIMPSON1.1.1 Tcl script onextalMAS.in |
SIMPSON1.1.0 Tcl script onextalMAS.in |
|||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
η = 1 | η = -1 | η = 1 | η = -1 | η = 1 | η = -1 | |
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 |
0 0.1908436366 0.1177854316 -0.1181422712 -0.1905155811 0.001057244221 0.1907815382 0.1133924352 -0.1248704872 -0.1859337477 0.02289503175 0.1977216871 0.07441321387 -0.1621577611 -0.1474539514 0.1001725545 0.1828394272 0.2477641061 0.01321514969 -0.1920845034 -0.1248137891 |
0 0.1909263462 0.1179498378 -0.1095760968 -0.1748410673 0.05933795078 0.349769756 0.3342515848 -0.2783335973 -0.4104664941 -0.04702774168 0.4073285563 0.3241038495 -0.1948624526 -0.4306262691 -0.05748909539 0.4018103486 0.3128637066 -0.1999188914 -0.4520927211 -0.01315623676 |
0 0.190926346 0.117949838 -0.109576097 -0.174841067 0.0593379508 0.349769756 0.334251585 -0.278333597 -0.410466494 -0.0470277417 0.407328556 0.32410385 -0.194862453 -0.430626269 -0.0574890954 0.401810349 0.312863707 -0.199918891 -0.452092721 -0.0131562368 |
0 0.190843637 0.117785432 -0.118142271 -0.190515581 0.00105724422 0.190781538 0.113392435 -0.124870487 -0.185933748 0.0228950317 0.197721687 0.0744132139 -0.162157761 -0.147453951 0.100172554 0.182839427 0.247764106 0.0132151497 -0.192084503 -0.124813789 |
0 0.190926346 0.117949838 -0.109576097 -0.174841067 0.0593379508 0.349769756 0.334251585 -0.278333597 -0.410466494 -0.0470277417 0.407328556 0.32410385 -0.194862453 -0.430626269 -0.0574890954 0.401810349 0.312863707 -0.199918891 -0.452092721 -0.0131562368 |
0 0.188972561 0.116081908 -0.11688695 -0.188263998 0.00261906922 0.189059486 0.117694207 -0.115041902 -0.18870292 -0.00390478132 0.18494291 0.127804355 -0.0722959819 0.0219328185 0.457229299 0.050283905 -0.349208801 -0.30430997 0.180687224 0.410775791 |
(D) Conclusions
- Mathematica-5 notebook cystal_MAS.nb, which uses the convention η = (VXX - VYY)/VZZ, and SIMPSON Tcl script, which uses the opposite convention η = (VYY - VXX)/VZZ, generate the same results if we choose the same convention for the asymmetry parameter.
- SIMPSON1.1.0 Tcl script with a negative value of η generates wrong results.